Autosomal dominant polycystic
kidney disease (ADPKD) remains a significant cause
of end stage renal disease. Unlike other
nephropathies, the role of angiotensin-converting
enzyme inhibitors (ACEi) is not as established in
ameliorating the rate of decline of renal function in
this disorder. We conducted a systematic review of
the literature to investigate if ACEi can slow the
progression to renal failure. Three were enalapril
comparative trials: two trials compared enalapril
against a calcium channel blocker and the other
against a beta blocker. Study quality was evaluated
using standardized criteria. Data was collected with
regards benefits and harms of theraphy, particularly
annual rate of decline of renal function and its
percentage against baseline. After mata-analysis,
there was a greater percentage decline in creatinine
clearance per year for groups treated with ACEi. This
was significant for the fixed effects model but not for
the random effects model. Reviewers conclude that
treatment with ACEi may not be the best option for
ADPKD patients with hypertension and close
monitoring is recommended. |